Hillsdale College | Chargers | A | 4 | Matthew Scanlon '25 | | Alya MacManaway '26 | 1-2,5-6,9-10 |
| | Luka Stanic '26 | 1-2,5-6,9-10 |
| | Riley Hamilton '25 | 3-4,7-8 |
| | Karis Moody '25 | 3-4,7-8 |
Indiana University | Hoosiers | A | 3 | Ian Knox '24 | | Anen Ricketts '27 | |
| | Zander West '26 | |
Reserves | Ian Knox '24 * |
University of Toledo | Rockets | A | 5 | Kassidy Kennedy '26 | | Nicholas Armantrout '26 | |
| | Alex Schlotterer '25 * | |
Reserves | Kassion Kennedy '26 * |
Western Michigan University | Broncos 1 | A | 1 | Keegan Aerts '25 | | William O'Haver '27 | |
| | Abigale Airo '24 | |
Western Michigan University | Broncos 2 | A | 2 | Jack LeFevre '24 | | William Moran '26 | 1-6 |
| | Megan Rakoczy '25 | 1-2 |
| | Evan Simpson '26 | 3-10 |
| | Lucas Posthumus Meyjes '27 | 7-10 |